NEW ROCHELLE, NY (January 25, 2024) — A New Rochelle man was arrested Tuesday after he brandished a 9mm handgun at a store on Sickles Avenue, police say.
On January 23rd. 2024, at about 5:59 pm, New Rochelle Police responded to Broccoli Smoke Shop at 394 North Avenue on a report of a menacing with a handgun. Upon arrival the suspect had already fled the scene.

At about 7:19 pm, Police received a call that the suspect returned. Police responded back and were able to arrest the suspect without incident.
The suspect was found to be in possession of a small silver 9mm handgun.
The incident started as a dispute between the suspect and the business owner.
Arrest & Charges:
Isaiah Sutton, 21, of New Rochelle, NY.
- Menacing – 2 with a weapon, a B Felony
- Criminal Possession of a Weapon – 2, a C Felony
UPDATE: CBS2 reports bail set at $10,000.
Discover more from Talk of the Sound
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
One thought on “Police Arrest New Rochelle Man Who Displayed Handgun at Smoke Shop”
Comments are closed.