NEW ROCHELLE, N.Y. — A New Rochelle City Court judge has ordered a mental competency examination for Samuel McVey, the former Isaac E. Young Middle School teacher now held at the Westchester County jail after failing to post bail, court records show.
All four criminal cases pending against McVey in New Rochelle City Court have been designated for a “730 status” hearing on June 2, 2026. While the charges against McVey are contained in four separate case filings, Talk of the Sound is reporting them as a single matter arising from the same course of conduct.
Under Section 730 of the New York Criminal Procedure Law, a 730 examination is ordered when a court has reason to question whether a defendant is mentally fit to understand the charges against him and participate in his own defense. Two psychiatric examiners are appointed to evaluate the defendant. If both find the defendant is not fit to proceed, the court may issue an order of observation or an order of commitment, suspending criminal proceedings and directing the defendant to a secure mental health facility for treatment. If the defendant is found fit, criminal proceedings resume.
A 730 designation does not constitute a finding of mental illness, nor does it indicate a defendant intends to pursue an insanity defense. It means only that the court has determined a competency evaluation is warranted.
McVey is next due in court June 2, 2026.
Background
Samuel McVey, 47, of Briarcliff Manor, was a probationary Spanish teacher at Isaac E. Young Middle School until January 2026, when Superintendent Corey W. Reynolds notified him of his intent to recommend termination.
In early February, McVey allegedly sent emails to a school official threatening to come to the school “with guns” and stating “we have a bullet for Corey’s head,” prompting heightened security at the school and a police investigation.
McVey faces charges in four separate cases in New Rochelle City Court, which Talk of the Sound is reporting as a single matter arising from the same course of conduct.
In the first case (CR-00564-26), McVey is charged with Aggravated Harassment in the Second Degree — Communicate Threat (PL 240.30 01), a Class A misdemeanor. An arrest warrant and temporary order of protection were issued on February 9. McVey was arrested at his parents’ home in Briarcliff Manor on March 17, arraigned before Judge Michelle Bernstein, pled not guilty, and was released under non-monetary conditions that included surrendering his passport — an order he did not comply with. He subsequently failed to appear in court on March 26 and again on April 1, triggering bench warrants on both dates.
In the second case (CR-01142-26), McVey is charged with Criminal Contempt in the Second Degree — Disobey Court (PL 215.50 03), a Class A misdemeanor. The case was initiated on March 20 with an arraignment and arrest warrant, with the warrant continued through March 24.
In the third case (CR-01830-26), McVey is charged with Criminal Contempt in the First Degree — Communicates (PL 215.51 BIII), a Class E felony. In the fourth case (CR-02011-26), McVey is charged with Bail Jumping in the Third Degree (PL 215.55), a Class A misdemeanor. Both cases were filed on April 24.
Talk of the Sound has asked the Westchester County District Attorney’s Office why the charges were filed as separate cases rather than consolidated; no response has been received.
McVey told Talk of the Sound he had been in Colombia since February 2026, initially planning to coordinate a baseball event during the New Rochelle schools’ mid-winter recess. He said he was interviewing for teaching positions, researching property for a planned bilingual school, and rented a finca in Llanogrande in early March. While Talk of the Sound was unable to independently verify those specific claims, records and witness accounts confirm McVey was present in Medellín as early as March 6 and was at an airport on March 12, as detailed in a previous Talk of the Sound report.
Court records show McVey was in New York on March 17 when he was arrested, and was back in Colombia by April 8. His movements between those dates are not fully known.
“While in Colombia in April, McVey engaged in conduct that authorities described as ‘behavior contrary to public coexistence,’ including, according to Colombian news reports and local officials posting on X, attempting to enter four separate schools and menacing students, parents, and staff. Colombian police took him into protective custody. Separately, and not previously publicly known, INDER Medellín, a sports agency of the Medellín Mayor’s Office, investigated McVey following a complaint of an on-field assault at a baseball facility. INDER confirmed that the District of Medellín, acting through the Mayor’s Office and in coordination with national immigration authorities, carried out ‘verification, control, and deportation’ of McVey, stating his presence in Colombia did not comply with migration regulations or the behavioral norms required of foreign nationals.”
There are conflicting accounts as to whether he was formally deported, but he returned to the United States through Miami, where he was not taken into custody because the charges he faced were misdemeanors, and subsequently went off the radar of law enforcement.
Westchester County prosecutors upgraded the charges to include a felony, Criminal Contempt in the First Degree, and added a bail jumping charge, placing him in the nationwide extraditable warrant system. Baton Rouge Police arrested him on May 7.. Westchester County Police Warrant/Fugitive Unit transported him to the New Rochelle Police Department pending arraignment on the new charges.
On May 8, warrants were executed across all pending cases. McVey was arraigned before Judge Bernstein, pled not guilty across all cases, and was unable to post bail. In the newest case, bail was set at $100,000 cash, $200,000 insured bond, or $300,000 partially secured surety bond. He is being held at the Westchester County Department of Correction in Valhalla. All four cases are next scheduled for a 730 status hearing on June 2, 2026.
This article was prepared with the assistance of AI tools under the direction and editing of Robert Cox.
Have information about this story? Email robertcox@talkofthesound.com or contact via WhatsApp: +353 89 972 0669.
RELATED